However, some students at Franciscan University felt otherwise.
"Dean Martin is still very relevant in our culture," said James Ellison, a computer science major. "That's Amore is basically the theme song of my life."
The students were joined by a small number of older Steubenville residents as well, albeit for slightly different reasons.
"They absolutely messed up Baby Heart Throb's mane," said longtime Steubenville resident David Stone. "Look at the colors they used. It's a disgrace to My Little Pony."
The change in artwork was largely supported around town, despite the fierce opposition from the younger age group.
"College kids will protest literally anything," said Dave Koresh, a local cat behavior consultant. "Last week those kids were protesting the Steubenville Cat Festival because of the dander cloud that blocked out the sun."
Koresh said that he enjoys the new theme, and hopes to see more murals like it.
"Honestly, it's a masterpiece," he said. "I hope the Market Street mural goes next. We've been trying to get Garfield painted over it since I was young."